China Economic Review
Charting China’s changing economic terrain · Since 1990

Sparks within the gloom

December 22, 2023

This has been a tough year all round, and in the China context, people were expecting it to be an up year after three devastating years of the pandemic. But it has not turned out that way. And the degree of consistency with which the middle-class in particular across China is taking a pessimistic view on the future is quite extraordinary. What the consequences are is still not clear, as is so much else in China. But it feels like a possible inflection point of some sort.

The property market remains in desperate straits, and the word on the street in most places is that the prices are expected to fall further before they stabilize, presumably. One has to give credit where credit is due, and given the incredible importance of the property market to the Chinese economy, and the depth of the problems that the market is facing, those in command have done a sterling job in keeping the boat stable over the past two years. Salami tactics in dealing with the debt burden, bailing out companies were necessary, diffusing local problems… While this has not solved the problem, it has at least prevented a total collapse. Which has to be good for everybody. However, have they also got to solve the problem. The news on that front this week was relatively positive. One, is that one of the most heavily indebted of the property developers, China South City managed to roll over some local bonds that it had been threatening to default on. This followed a similar last minute rescue for Country Garden, another massive property developer in very difficult states, just a couple of weeks ago. But the point remains, that nobody in their right mind is going to be buying in this market and the extent to which people feel for whatever reason and to what degree of accuracy, this is not a cyclical issue, but one that is somehow fundamental and systemic, makes it hard to see how this is going to be resolved.

Another spark of hope was generated by a move, again by those in command, to reduce the number of close fly-pasts of American surveillance planes in the general vicinity of China, over what are considered by most of the world to be international waters. The possibly of an accident occurring, such as occurred in 2001 off Hainan, is real, and it could lead to hot war. So the decision to pull back on this is welcomed, even though it could be reversed any time. There is a general sense, and one must not be too categorical about this, of a desire to cool geopolitical issues, which would make total sense. And more of that in 2024, please.

We will sum up the year and provide some thoughts on next year in our weekly missive next week. But it is worth saying here that this is as extraordinary a time for Chinese society and the economy as we have witnessed in many a year. How things are within the system, of course, is unknown. but the conclusion of the economic work conference about 10 days ago, which carefully balanced off the needs of security and development, suggested that there was no clear agreement at the top about which to stress. This is worth pondering during the impending festive season, if you’re looking for a break from Christmas songs. Have a great weekend.

Forecasts

December 8, 2023

Moody’s is a credit rating agency which looks at companies, countries and territories, and takes a view on the state of their economy and finances and then assigns them a rating. This week, Moody’s lowered its rating of both the China mainland economy and the Hong Kong economy into negative territory and this was the cause of much consternation. According to the Financial Times, Moody’s staff were advised to avoid going to the office, and the Hong Kong government issued a statement saying that this was another example of western forces looking for opportunities to “smear” China and Hong Kong.

We are approaching the end of the year, and this is the time when many analysts, economists and organizations are taking a view on the year ahead. Surprisingly, quite a few of the investment banks, and other finance operations are taking a view which is neutral to cautiously positive in terms of 2024 compared to 2023. This year was supposed to have been the year of a major rebound from three years drenched in Covid troubles, but the rebound basically doesn’t seem to have happened, and the overall assessment of China in the business community, both in terms of published analysis and anecdotal opinions, is certainly not positive. And with investment banks, one always has to take their assessments with a grain of salt in that they inevitably want to see business growing, so that they can make more money.

The feeling on the ground is definitely gloomy in terms of next year, and there are lots of things happening which tend to suggest that there are significant problems lurking within the system and in the economy. This is a structure which is highly controlled and highly centralized, and that limits the extent to which events can trigger some kind of a reaction. But there is always the possibility of the unexpected. In fact, in a system with such a low degree of transparency, the unexpected is in fact to be expected.

And so our analysis is, for what it’s worth, that China is facing several years of difficulties. And the stresses within Chinese society, and between China and some parts of the rest of the world will continue to be present, and will probably be exacerbated. This is not an outlook that leads to optimism. And we wish that it was not so, because there are surely ways to make China into a system that is growing and positive. But to get there could require some fundamental changes, such as the shifting the balance of assets between households and the system which would impact on the interests of various groups. And there is also the fundamental ideological issue of what is the right direction to make sure China and its people are safe.

Generally, it’s true that investors, both foreign and Chinese, today seem reluctant to invest for all sorts of reasons, including the presence of geopolitical risk. One always hopes for the best, and over the past few decades, the Chinese economy has always found a way of overcoming issues, even if it means kicking the problem down the road and then finding a way to quietly resolve it. And that will be almost certainly part of the story over next year and the following years. The question is how big the strains and stresses are and the potential for something fundamental to occur if these stresses and strains are not reduced.

Anyway, that is just a thought prior to the weekend, which we hope will be a pleasant one for you.

The wheel of history

December 1, 2023

This week saw the end of an era with the passing of Henry Kissinger, at the age of 100. He is today very much associated with China, but the way it started back in the early 1970s was that Dr K’s main goal was to counter the threat of the Soviet Union by creating an alliance with China that undercut Moscow’s position. His geopolitical game had huge consequences for China and unquestionably had the positive consequence of helping to trigger a shift that, in due course after Mao’s death, resulted in an opening up process and market reforms. China being a part of the world rather than isolated is obviously a good thing. But the question then and now is precisely the nature of China’s integration into the world and the nature of the relationship between China and the rest of the world. Kissinger’s view, to hyperbolize dramatically, was one of appeasement, that is allowing China to hold to a worldview which is to some extent at variance with that of the global framework in general and the West specifically. The idea was that if we allowed them into the tent, then they will see the superior nature of the other system and change. It didn’t turn out like that. But Kissinger, for reasons arguably linked to his own business interests, stuck to his original line and had a significant impact on US policy and by extension the policies other countries for decades afterwards.

This week was also noteworthy for another historical reason. Mr Xi made his first visit to Shanghai in four years. There was some speculation about whether the visit would be used to signal a sharp and definitive shift towards market friendly policies, mirroring Deng’s visit to the city in 1992 which unleashed massive economic development. But the read-outs of the visit so far in the state media do not indicate that the visit will be used to signal any fundamental changes to current policy lines. History marches on regardless.

Have a great weekend.

Juggling balls

November 24, 2023

It’s got to be getting harder for them. There is a growing sense of economic gloom, and of the possibility that black swans and grey rhinos are lying out there in wait, particularly in the finance and property sector. The top news of the week was of the massive wealth management conglomerate Zhongzhi Enterprise Group declaring itself to be “severely insolvent,” with debts amounting to $65 billion, double its assets. “Severely insolvent” sounds like “a little bit pregnant,” but such a financial position can be created only by a massive number of bad decisions and a precipitous change in market conditions. Or, of course, both.

In the property market, Sunac China Holdings announced it had reached agreement on rolling over and reorganizing its huge debts, but the question is whether, with the time thus bought, the company is able to finish its stalled projects and deliver apartments to consumers who have paid their deposits, and also make new sales. The former is going to be easier than the latter. Who is going to buy an apartment in this market? Evergrande went through a similar process a couple of years ago, but the context has changed significantly since then. Anyway, congratulations to Sunac for at the least kicking the can down the road a fair way.

Apocalyptic scenarios are best avoided. This system has too many means to maintain apparent stability in the dynamic soup that is the Chinese economy. But it feels anecdotally and atmospherically as if next year is going to tougher than this year, albeit with some bright spots such as EVs. But even there, Nio was supposed to be the future, and now it is facing problems. Ai-yaaa.

Meanwhile, with one sonar pulse the sense of improvement in Sino-Oz relations evaporated. The world is getting really complicated. But that’s no reason not to enjoy the weekend ahead. Go for it!

Buying time

November 17, 2023

The China system is facing a whole bunch of domestic problems, economic and social, structural and financial, and it has long been argued by some that this is not a good time to be at loggerheads in so many directions externally. The Ukraine war created a rift with Europe, and the relationship with the US has been continually exacerbated by a long list of issues. It hurts investor sentiment, it’s not good for business, it’s a deadweight on the economy which is quite obviously slowing down.

The message appears to have got through, at least partially, and Mr Xi met with Mr Biden in San Francisco in order, it seems, to create a positive vibe. It worked. There was an agreement on military communications and another to stop the flow of fentanyl-creating chemicals and equipment across the Pacific, but then one remembers the meeting in the White House with Obama a decade ago at which there was a pledge to stop the industrial espionage.

There was a declaration by the two sides of their basic positions on Taiwan, but in such a way to suggest, it seems, that probably maybe there is nothing planned to disrupt the status quo anytime soon. That comment is an extrapolation of vibe rather than of any concrete wording, but if there is one issue that makes investors nervous and wary, it is the opacity on intentions with regard to the island. Even a hint of clarity in the direction of “nothing to see here” is helpful. And that is presumably the perception he wanted to create.

It is all, in the words of a wise commentator, an effort to “slow down the slowdown.” It is buying time. Whether it is reflective of anything more fundamental than that in terms of a shift towards pragmatism and away from holding firmly to the key ideological links, only time will tell. But this meeting was at least a good sign.

So this weekend, dear readers, it is okay to sleep a little easier.